Hey Commish! All Fantasy Football Leagues Should Adopt These Ideas

Fantasy football leagues can go stale. Communication drops off, the camaraderie wanes, and sometimes leagues just die off as people relocate and move on in life. Having been a commissioner of a league for 15 years, here are some fantasy football league ideas I’ve found that I believe every league should adopt to bring some life back.

Invest in a trophy that is iconic, unique

Take some pride in your fantasy league and give it a lasting tradition! Don’t spend $150 on a generic, forgettable trophy someone will lose or will be “accidentally” thrown away by a spouse. Instead, create something that your league will WANT and want to show off. Case in point: our league’s 44-pound brick of solid steel; making it one of the heaviest sports trophies on the planet. Only took a trip to a steel shop and then a local engraver. All in cost: $274 for a work of art. Well worth it to keep everyone excited about the league.

Create an experimental league for testing

League changes are a given; the game of football changes. But, don’t haphazardly change league settings before giving them a test run in an experimental league: a copy of the exact players and teams but with far less money required. Make the dues $20 to keep people invested, and try out small changes year after year, then decide whether or not to implement a league vote during the off-season.

You’ll be surprised how many ideas that seem great at the time are horrible in practice (e.g. individual defensive player). Giving fantasy football league ideas a chance to be perfected makes certain they fit.

Create traditions

Nothing creates loyalty like tradition. And if you want to have a thriving league with lots of communication, trades, and fun, you’ll have to create some traditions. Below are some of our league’s best:

  1. Keep the Sacko (last-place finisher) punishment the same for a set number of years
  2. Create league merch every 3 years
  3. Require an in-person (and destination?) draft every 5 years
  4. Hire a sports personality on Cameo to do a draft kickoff video. (Hands off Dean Blandino, he’s ours)

If done right, you’ll start to develop a waiting list of friends who want to join your league. Ours currently has a backlog of 3 players.

A league constitution with rules & amendments

As a commissioner, you know the difficulty of wrangling a group of passionate and irrational humans into agreement. The only way to mitigate these inevitably asinine arguments is to have some pretty ironclad rules. It may seem ridiculous or over the top, but the only way to avoid any mid-season knockdown, drag-out, curse fests between players is a good set of guidelines.

Take the time to document all of your league’s rules (both written and un-written) and then have everyone vote to agree to them. Any amendments or changes should not be allowed during the season and should be voted on during the off-season.

The surprising thing about this process? It’s fun. It gets everyone to buy into the process and gets them more personally invested in the league.

Furthermore, every 5 years or so, you should think about a Constitutional Convention where all of the rules are re-evaluated and where new amendments can be proposed and voted on.

Create a triumvirate to assist the commissioner

Conflict of interest is the primary reason here, but also because sometimes being the commissioner can be stressful and difficult on your own. Create a group of 3 people (commissioner included) who can provide further clarity, support, or unbiased opinion should a situation arise where the result would directly impact the commissioner’s team.

Be sure to rotate the triumvirate members with the most rational and objective players in your league. This also distributes the anger from any aggrieved party and creates less unilateral friction.

Added suggestion: Let your triumvirate act like the Supreme Court when making determinations. Then you get gems like below.

Which reminds me, get a website

A place to document everything that happens is ESSENTIAL. Otherwise, you’ll be up scrolling for hours trying to find that one group text where everyone decided on one tiny rule that you forgot about. There are a million no-code website builders out there, take your pick and start documenting big decisions, rules, past winners, run polls, and your new cameo videos.

You’ll never regret spending the small yearly cost to run the site and everyone will appreciate the transparency.


Do you have some more ideas or think mine are total garbage? Let us know on Twitter / X! Or Threads @pokatok_fest.

Festival Updates

SportsTechX, The Player’s Impact & MassChallenge Join as Major Conference Partners

We're excited to announce some key programming and networking partners for the PokatokX sports conference.

GeneralOur Takes

AL Wild Card Race Heats Up As October Approaches

Jay Arnold talks about the AL Wild Card Race as three teams look to lock down two spots left in the post-season as we close in on October.

GeneralOur Takes

NL Wild Card Race Sets Up Thrilling Conclusion to MLB Regular Season

Jay Arnold dives into the NL Wild Card Race and predicts who he thinks finds their way into the Major League Baseball postseason.

Our Takes

Champions League Predictions

With Champions League action about to kick off in Europe, Bav gives his predictions on who he sees advancing from the Group Stage.